Yes, the MMR system is not out yet, but this is just your opinion off what BHVR gave us so far
A functional one.
I'm saying current color based, since I have a strong feeling that the MMR system will be even worse...
I don't like, but is better than MMR
I think MMR is a good idea altogether, I see and agree with the points mentioned in the status update post.
Also, I hope there will be more details about the scoring system, it would be interesting to look into it more in depth.
MMR is better in THEORY but given that no one can agree what is a win Its a complete gamble to try it.
However at this point with how bad the match making is there is almost nothing left to lose with trying it.
I'm really waiting forward to the MMR system or something that actually determines skill. Currently the game puts me into red ranks as survivor anyway while I am actually garbage with the chases but I manage to do a lot of other things well like looking after other survivors. Current system doesn't know if a player is good so I end up facing a lot of godlike rank 1 killers because of it and it usually isn't fun at all when I can't even run away from them for 5s before I go down.
Also why did they ever think it's a good idea to have achievements for the ranking system in the first place? It's a rank so it means that clearly not everyone is meant to ever reach rank 1 as it should determine your rank as it suggests. Not everyone can be so good at the game, it's there only to make the games fair and exciting for both sides. Hopefully the new system ensures that more commonly.