Not a big fan of the other maps either but I can't figure out how to play Hawkins.
Dislike all of them for different reasons.
The Game is dark on the lower levels, has strong pallets but is very easy to 3 gen.
Hawkins is small, but some killers struggle using there power effectively. Has a mix of poor loops and great loops if strung together.
Lery's is too big and complicated with all of it's rooms. Looks amazing but just too complicated.
Midwhich, my least favourite, is just extremely bland. All loops are extremely average, killer struggles rotating around gens because there are only three ways up to the second floor, while survivors struggle stringing loops together as they have to go from room to room which are seldom connected.
To be fair, I kind of like them all. I hated Hawkins at release because it was impossible to find my way in here, and now I have the same problem with Midwich. But I'm guessing it will get better in time. And I really love the design of Midwich, so I'll have to go with Hawkins.
I think Midwich Elementary School looks the best out of all of them but I find it difficult to play on as both survivor and killer.
Midwich and The Game are the only maps that I don't enjoy playing at all. Midwich has a huge OoO problem and loops aren't particularly engaging for either side. The fact that the second floor has no route from one side to the other also makes catching an Object take way too long. Essentially killers are put in a lose lose where they either waste all their time chasing the Object that's halfway across the map, or they give the survivors free info. It's also a bit rough trying to find generators on this map, but that could just be me. Visually though, this map is one of the best ones, it's just a shame that I hate it.
With The Game almost every pallet is safe, which makes them less engaging than on Midwich, but at least OoO isn't as problematic on that map. This map is also loads more fun with Nurse, Doc, Legion, Trapper, and Hag.
I have always hated Gideon Meat Packing Plant. The bathroom gen sucks, the small size sucks against Doctor. Have only played 3 matches on Midwich since I started playing the game again, so I can't offer a great opinion on it though.
Hawkins Lab not a fan and i love Midwich Elementary School.
because it is just so bad, some bad pallets that are just stupid, no good pallets,
The game, is ok, has strong pallets, and it's easy to 3 gen, so they cancell each other.
lary's .... = it's ok, it's kinda complex but you can loop some time if you get some good windows.
Hawkins = A map where are some bad pallets, but some safer ones, and some good windows after all.. still not a huge fan, but better then the other maps.
Also, there is a glitch in the "midwich elementry school"....
Haven't played enough Midwich to judge it fairly, so Hawkins.
Midwitch looks sick but plays like trash.
Always be the most hated one for me.