Home Dead by Daylight Forums Discussions General Discussions

Who do you think you would beat in a fight?



  • SunsetSherbetSunsetSherbet Member Posts: 1,292

    Amanda. Pretty much the only one. She's physically weak (it's a plot point that she's not strong enough to lift an adult woman into a trap) and has no combat training or really anything special to her. She just nabs people and puts them in traps. In a fight, I don't think she has a lot going for her. Even her weapon is a bit meh.

    And Maybe Ghostie.

  • SepexSepex Member Posts: 999

    None. I'm a lover not a fighter.

  • DeadSacrificeDeadSacrifice Member Posts: 86

    She does have a little bit of combat training but not much

  • TheGannManTheGannMan Member Posts: 8,518

    Rin would kill all of them with no bumps or bruises.

  • DeadSacrificeDeadSacrifice Member Posts: 86

    The question is can you beat a raging school girl with a katana that can phase and has years of internal rage answer: uhh i dont think so

  • TAGTAG Member Posts: 12,042

    Nemesis. I assume his rocket launcher is nearby. ;)

  • KurriKurri Member Posts: 1,601

    None. Because they are all famous murderers with weapons, and powers granted by an eldritch entity I have no knowledge of.

    I would at least try to reason with Cenobite, since they could be reasoned with in the movies.

  • Huge_BushHuge_Bush Member Posts: 3,084
    edited January 19

    You have to specify if its the killers empowered by the entity version or without the entity power up. If it's with the entities power up, I'll die to all of them, though they will spend a long time looking for me. If it's not their powered up version, Trickster and Legion (yes, I know, all four). I'd pick off Legion one by one by smashing pallets on their heads.

    If I'm lucky enough to be on a map with a vehicle, I'll hot wire it and run them all over. As for Trickster, I'd hop in a locker, wait for him to open it and lunch myself at him using one of his blades from the locker, and finish him off by crushing him with my weight.

    Anyone else, I'd probably try climbing over the wall and jumping off of the cliff.

  • QwQwQwQw Member Posts: 4,298

    Not to sound mean, but I feel like a lot of people here are greatly exaggerating their ability to fight. Every single killer, yes, even Hag, could probably kick your ass.

  • TotemSeeker91TotemSeeker91 Member Posts: 804

    Yeah, but he's a scrawny nerd, i could totally take him, lol

  • DeadSacrificeDeadSacrifice Member Posts: 86


  • DeadSacrificeDeadSacrifice Member Posts: 86

    No really anybody could kick her ass easily max 10 secs

  • AkumakajiAkumakaji Member Posts: 1,125

    Plage: she is a tall woman, but spindly and wracked by a terrible desease. Sure, I would probably die a week later, but that spindly arms of her? That gonna snap if she tries her projectile vomiting shenanigans.

    The Hag though I wouldn't want to go near. Her emaciated form is empowered by The Entity from head to toe and I wouldn't trust myself beating her at arm wrestling with both my hands vs her weak hand.

  • SuzuKRSuzuKR Member Posts: 2,008
    edited January 19

    People are ignoring literally every single one of these killers is on magical super steroids from a literal evil Eldritch world-devouring god.

    Even without the steroids, having a weapon is a massive difference. It doesn’t matter if they’re an idiot that doesn’t know how to use it properly, they still have a lethal weapon. One wrong injury and you’re dying. And they don’t have qualms about killing. So they wouldn’t have issues going for killing blows immediately.

  • DeadSacrificeDeadSacrifice Member Posts: 86

    Yes the Legion Clan could maby defeat them but they can hop over the pallets too

  • DeadSacrificeDeadSacrifice Member Posts: 86

    Well some of us are going of them without the Entitys power

  • SuzuKRSuzuKR Member Posts: 2,008

    Edited my post earlier to factor that in:

    Even without the steroids, having a weapon is a massive difference. It doesn’t matter if they’re an idiot that doesn’t know how to use it properly, they still have a lethal weapon. One wrong injury and you’re dying. And they don’t have qualms about killing. So they wouldn’t have issues going for killing blows immediately.

  • DeadSacrificeDeadSacrifice Member Posts: 86
    edited January 19

    But you cant harm her with her own disease and she does have corrupt vomit too think about that too

  • DeadByStreetlightDeadByStreetlight Member Posts: 150

    Doctor -> Eat an apple (I don't know why but it works)

    Ghostface -> Not accepting calls from strangers

    Demogorgon -> Placing dog food somewhere and sneak to the exit

    Ok realistically no one. 😞

  • QwQwQwQw Member Posts: 4,298

    I disagree. While Hag may look physically weak, she can still take the same hits every other killer can, hit just as hard as every other killer, and carry full grown men around with one arm. Plus, with the way she scuttles about, she is likely very agile and would be hard to hit.

    Also, OP mentions how you are unprepared. That means that Hag could have already set up her web of traps, (which is just instant death), and you are likely unarmed.

  • BlackRabiesBlackRabies Member Posts: 490

    The only killer be even possible that can be beaten maybe would be Amanda/Pig as she's a scrawny drug addicted women. If you get caught up in one of her traps though good as dead.

  • SpitefulHatefulSpitefulHateful Member Posts: 135

    Trickster. Use a chair as a shield from his knives, knee him in the groin before he switches to the bat, tase him and then use his own bat to beat the living crap out of him. Then tase his ass again for a good measure.

    Legion. Wear my backpack in front of me to protect myself from knives, use a taser and a flammable hairspray to set them on fire. Either use the ruckus to go for the gun safe and delete them or knock out one of the girls with a taser and use her as a meatshield and proceed to the gun safe. Or go to Valhalla trying to pull it all off.

    Amanda. Use a makeshift flamethrower to make sure she is too disoriented to stab or inject me or make her remove her mask, smack her on the head with a vase, use a mace spray on her while she is unconscious to make sure she won't be in the rate state to try and escape while waiting for the police.

  • DoritoHeadDoritoHead Member Posts: 2,627

    Are you sure about Legion? That's FOUR edgy teenagers who all have knives, plus they're Canadian.

  • DoritoHeadDoritoHead Member Posts: 2,627

    I have nothing better to do so I'm just going to evaluate all of them.

    Trapper- Probably not.

    Wraith- I could maybe land a few good hits before dying, if not for his cloak I think I'd have a chance.

    Hillbilly- Would probably knock me out immediately with his hammer

    Nurse- Would be hard to hit, but if I do land a hit I think I could win

    Shape- I would die but I wouldn't mind

    Hag- She would literally go down in one kick. EZ win.

    Doctor- I'd be incapacitated before I got the chance to even throw a punch

    Huntress- I'd die, but judging by that anime fight scene in her archive, it would look extremely cool

    Cannibal- Can't do much to a guy with a chainsaw

    Nightmare- Death

    Pig- I have a fair shot, I'd just need to make sure she doesn't get the chance to slash my neck.

    Clown- He'd probably throw bottles at me until I was too weak to fight, then go in for the kill. If he doesn't do that, I think I can outmaneuver him.

    Spirit- Would I even be able to hit her? Or would my hands go through her because she's a ghost? I think I have a fair chance if not.

    Legion- I could 1v1 any of them and win as long as I had SOMETHING to use, even if it was a big stick. But in a 4v1 I would lose, especially because I wouldn't be able to bring myself to hurt Joey.

    Plague- Win, but then die later from the disease

    Ghost Face- If I happen to have some sort of weapon on me I have a small chance, otherwise I'm dead meat.

    Demogorgon- Demo would tear me to ribbons

    Oni- Bonk.

    Deathslinger- I don't think Caleb is a poor shot, but If I can dodge the redeemer then I can beat him.

    Executioner- If beating him by coming to terms with my guilt and grief isn't an option, then there's no way I'm winning.

    Blight- At first glace it would seem easy but anyone who is able to slam themselves into walls at breakneck speed and shrug it off can probably beat me no problem.

    Twins- Victor would be easy, but Charlotte not so much. I give myself a 50/50 chance of winning.

    Trickster- Trickster doesn't even know how to fight.

    Nemesis- Lmao

    Cenobite- Nah.

    Artist- I don't really see how Ink can hurt me, So I guess I can win.

Sign In or Register to comment.