Home Discussions General Discussions

Most boring killer to play as or against?

2

Comments

  • JanTheManJanTheMan Member Posts: 495
    Blueberry said:

    Legion for both. Either he has Franks tape and you get downed with no counter play or he doesn't and just follows your blood. Both requiring no skill on either side and both having no counter play.

    Other than Legion I hate playing against Billy's. He isn't punished enough for chainsaw miss plays and the chainsaws reach/maneuverability feels VERY forgiving. When you go down it just feels..cheap.

    This
  • EesaneEesane Member Posts: 27

    Legion for both. stab everyone, you get stabbed and you, and you. It's either franks mixed tape OR they stab you with frenzy then moonwalk or look up to drop chase; while technically still following you so your timer goes down.

    For those complaining about billy might have never played him and tried chainsawing someone in an open field and having them move out of your way at the last second to miss. Remember there are bad billys, that's why they might run noed.

  • KoolaidInMyCupKoolaidInMyCup Member Posts: 20

    Speaking of Legion I actually tried out an alternative to Franks Mix Tape and Stab Wounds.

    Fuming Mix Tape (See Gen Prog while Frenzied) with the new Surveillance Buff and Discordance you can actually play Gen Protector Legion which is alot more balanced and fair.

    Considering this option exists now, If youre running Franks youre literally just being a [BAD WORD] for no reason.

  • MegMain98MegMain98 Member Posts: 2,491

    @BunnyBuns said:
    Nurse, since more than half the matches on rank 1 and 2 seem to be Nurse.

    I'm seriously starting to consider just suiciding against Nurse if it keeps up.

    Same. I’m on PS4 so I didn’t have a reason to fear Nurse players because usually they aren’t great even at red ranks. Let me tell you...more than HALF of my games last night were God tier Nurses. I appreciated it at first because it was a rarity but dying over and over and over again to the most powerful killer in the game just seemed cheap. There isn’t anything you can do to a Nurse but hope her prediction is wrong and mind-games herself.

    All you can do is hope you aren’t the first one caught because if you are, you’ll have to be good at surviving and hope your teammates aren’t potatoes and actually fix generators.

  • Lanis_Lanis_ Member Posts: 183
    Amanda to play (even I like play against, for the idea of another task to survivor).
    To play against i think Legion, too boring..

  • KhermaKherma Member Posts: 24

    @MegMain98 said:
    Same. I’m on PS4 so I didn’t have a reason to fear Nurse players because usually they aren’t great even at red ranks. Let me tell you...more than HALF of my games last night were God tier Nurses. I appreciated it at first because it was a rarity but dying over and over and over again to the most powerful killer in the game just seemed cheap. There isn’t anything you can do to a Nurse but hope her prediction is wrong and mind-games herself.

    All you can do is hope you aren’t the first one caught because if you are, you’ll have to be good at surviving and hope your teammates aren’t potatoes and actually fix generators.

    I wouldn't say it's cheap, if someone has practiced a lot to get good with Nurse. On console especially.
    I play at rank 1 with Nurse on PS4 and i see survivors doing same mistakes over and over again. Then it's a very "cheap" victory for Nurse. For example, a survivor keep pallet looping the Nurse. Or a survivor try to "backtrack" the Nurse. Okay, it's much better way than pallet looping but still doing it every single time… Easy to predict. And you can see this kinda stuff at rank 1, i am a very disappointed (lol not really, i can't even myself survive against god Nurses). :lol:

    Most boring killer to play against is the Legion. The hole game is just healing... And when Legion use thanatophobia and sloppy butcher and you don't even have self care, it's gg then

  • DudeDeliciousDudeDelicious Member Posts: 7,606
    The most boring killer to go against are the ones that set up a bot to just stand there swinging their weapon over and over. 
  • MegMain98MegMain98 Member Posts: 2,491

    @Kherma said:

    @MegMain98 said:
    Same. I’m on PS4 so I didn’t have a reason to fear Nurse players because usually they aren’t great even at red ranks. Let me tell you...more than HALF of my games last night were God tier Nurses. I appreciated it at first because it was a rarity but dying over and over and over again to the most powerful killer in the game just seemed cheap. There isn’t anything you can do to a Nurse but hope her prediction is wrong and mind-games herself.

    All you can do is hope you aren’t the first one caught because if you are, you’ll have to be good at surviving and hope your teammates aren’t potatoes and actually fix generators.

    I wouldn't say it's cheap, if someone has practiced a lot to get good with Nurse. On console especially.
    I play at rank 1 with Nurse on PS4 and i see survivors doing same mistakes over and over again. Then it's a very "cheap" victory for Nurse. For example, a survivor keep pallet looping the Nurse. Or a survivor try to "backtrack" the Nurse. Okay, it's much better way than pallet looping but still doing it every single time… Easy to predict. And you can see this kinda stuff at rank 1, i am a very disappointed (lol not really, i can't even myself survive against god Nurses). :lol:

    Most boring killer to play against is the Legion. The hole game is just healing... And when Legion use thanatophobia and sloppy butcher and you don't even have self care, it's gg then

    Understandable because it is SUPER hard to master Nurse on console, I’m trash at playing Nurse. I went against probably 8 Nurses last night and it was the same thing over and over again with a long chase and my teammates doing nothing. I can predict pretty well where a Nurse thinks I’m gonna go and go the opposite way so she mind games herself, but it only takes two mistakes on my part and I’m are downed and hooked. Just feels kinda cheap to die over and over again to THE BEST killer in the game. Just nothing you can do against a Nurse besides try to break line of sight and make her mind game herself.

    I was just having a bad night due to the abundance and Billys and Nurses. I’d honestly rather go against a Nurse than Billy though, I HATE going against Billys.

  • GraviteaUKGraviteaUK Member Posts: 464

    Hillbilly or Bubba for sure. both to play as and against.

    1. Find survivor
    2. Walk behind survivor
    3. Press RC

    Fun and interactive gameplay.

    Bonus points for movement speed addons on Bubba or Charge time on Billy.

  • NathanExplosionNathanExplosion Member Posts: 337
    edited February 2019

    @Poweas said:

    @NathanExplosion said:
    They're all rodeo clowns for survivors, except Nurse.

    What's your point OP ?

    Except Billy, Hag/Spirit. The top tier killers are never rodeo clowns, they're dominant as hell.

    I agree that these 3 are indeed top tier compared to the others.

    But against an optimal survivor team, only Nurse stand a chance, and even there it's tedious.

    Buffing the lower-tier to Billy's level would be a good start, indeed.

  • MegMain98MegMain98 Member Posts: 2,491

    @NathanExplosion said:

    @Poweas said:

    @NathanExplosion said:
    They're all rodeo clowns for survivors, except Nurse.

    What's your point OP ?

    Except Billy, Hag/Spirit. The top tier killers are never rodeo clowns, they're dominant as hell.

    I agree that these 3 are indeed top tier compared to the others.

    But against an optimal survivor team, only Nurse stand a chance, and even there it's tedious.

    Buffing the lower-tier to Billy's level would be a good start, indeed.

    Not every killer will be nor needs to be on Nurse/Billy level. Tell me how exactly Freddy or Wraith will EVER be as powerful as those two? Their powers are just not as good as top tier killers. If they stand any chance of being buffed it needs to be their OWN power that gets the buff. Not a general killer buff. Nurse and Billy don’t need it, Freddy and Wraith do.

    Sorry if I may have misunderstood you, but that is how I interpreted it.

  • NathanExplosionNathanExplosion Member Posts: 337
    edited February 2019

    @MegMain98 said:

    Not every killer will be nor needs to be on Nurse/Billy level. Tell me how exactly Freddy or Wraith will EVER be as powerful as those two? Their powers are just not as good as top tier killers. If they stand any chance of being buffed it needs to be their OWN power that gets the buff. Not a general killer buff. Nurse and Billy don’t need it, Freddy and Wraith do.

    Sorry if I may have misunderstood you, but that is how I interpreted it.

    Of course i'm talking about changing them individually to, at least, close the gap between them and Billy.

    I know that everyone of them are different and that they can't mechanically all be at this level, but i also know for sure that actually the difference is so big that it's laughtable.

    But hey, knowing these Devs, i know it's not gonna happen ^^

  • ClogWenchClogWench Member Posts: 2,583
    Spend most of my time against Leatherface sitting on a hook staring at his face so I'd say he's up there.
  • ArrozArroz Member Posts: 1,434

    @Delfador said:
    The most boring killer is hands down the legion.

    Other than him, I don't know. If the team is bad, going against spirits and nurses is just frustrating because you do everything you could do and then the next person gets downed in like 10 seconds. I don't find them boring though.

    The most enjoyable killers to go against is hillbilly and huntress.

    Lmao, you serious that [BAD WORD] possy killer? the huntress aka broken hitboxes? yeah instachainsaw billy is "fun", the only fun killer to play against is pig and scary myers.

  • DelfadorDelfador Member Posts: 2,553

    @Arroz said:

    @Delfador said:
    The most boring killer is hands down the legion.

    Other than him, I don't know. If the team is bad, going against spirits and nurses is just frustrating because you do everything you could do and then the next person gets downed in like 10 seconds. I don't find them boring though.

    The most enjoyable killers to go against is hillbilly and huntress.

    Lmao, you serious that [BAD WORD] possy killer? the huntress aka broken hitboxes? yeah instachainsaw billy is "fun", the only fun killer to play against is pig and scary myers.

    Please for the love of god, fck off if you don't know how to talk to people.

    Why am I a killer here? I am a solo survivor and I rarely play killers and even then I just play the clown. I almost never touch hillbilly as well.

    My play ratio is less then 9 to 1, 9 being the survivor.

    Lmao, you serious that [BAD WORD] possy survivor? Pig aka the worst killer? Yeah scary myers who can't catch up is so fun.

    Jesus

  • IhatelifeIhatelife Member Posts: 4,313

    Nurse and legion to play against.
    To play as Freddy. His power is just boring and not effective.

  • IhatelifeIhatelife Member Posts: 4,313

    @NathanExplosion said:
    They're all rodeo clowns for survivors, except Nurse.

    What's your point OP ?

    So you just thinks that the spirit, hag and billy are rodeo clowns? They are extremely deadly in the hands of expierience player.

  • NathanExplosionNathanExplosion Member Posts: 337

    @Ihatelife

    @NathanExplosion said:

    @Poweas said:

    @NathanExplosion said:
    They're all rodeo clowns for survivors, except Nurse.

    What's your point OP ?

    Except Billy, Hag/Spirit. The top tier killers are never rodeo clowns, they're dominant as hell.

    I agree that these 3 are indeed top tier compared to the others.

    But against an optimal survivor team, only Nurse stand a chance, and even there it's tedious.

    Buffing the lower-tier to Billy's level would be a good start, indeed.

  • Mc_HartyMc_Harty Member Posts: 3,294

    Legion... Everything about him is so brainless.

  • BossBoss Member, Trusted Posts: 10,123

    As: Nurse.
    Against: Legion.

  • PoweasPoweas Member Posts: 5,875

    @NathanExplosion said:

    @Poweas said:

    @NathanExplosion said:
    They're all rodeo clowns for survivors, except Nurse.

    What's your point OP ?

    Except Billy, Hag/Spirit. The top tier killers are never rodeo clowns, they're dominant as hell.

    I agree that these 3 are indeed top tier compared to the others.

    But against an optimal survivor team, only Nurse stand a chance, and even there it's tedious.

    Buffing the lower-tier to Billy's level would be a good start, indeed.

    You're sort of wrong. Billy and Spirit do well against SWF. Billy can slug the hell out of them and Spirit can end chases faster than Nurse (I seriously need to learn Spirit, Nurse was so easy but Spirit is hard) so she'd be great at beating a SWF. It's just Hag. If you trap certain loops only, Hag will not do well against SWF. Only time I can see Hag doing well is if the Hag shuts down their path not the loops. So their path to the loop is closed. Kind of like how Tru3 does it but way more unpredictable.

  • Doc_W__HOLLIDAYDoc_W__HOLLIDAY Member Posts: 2,346
    Hands-down: Trapper
  • feechimafeechima Member Posts: 535

    Worse/boring killer to go against for me is Freddy. I get that it's a excellent technique to keep everyone sleep so you know where they are, but when Freddy uses Nancy's Masterpiece to put you alseep at crazy ranges I want to DC every time (but I don't) because its a constant battle of wake up, sleep, wu, sl, wu, sl. Also Freddy's tend to tunnel as they are prone to obsession builds.

  • MegMain98MegMain98 Member Posts: 2,491

    @feechima said:
    Worse/boring killer to go against for me is Freddy. I get that it's a excellent technique to keep everyone sleep so you know where they are, but when Freddy uses Nancy's Masterpiece to put you alseep at crazy ranges I want to DC every time (but I don't) because its a constant battle of wake up, sleep, wu, sl, wu, sl. Also Freddy's tend to tunnel as they are prone to obsession builds.

    I understand...we all have those killers we want to DC against. Everytime I see Legion or Freddy I have the urge to DC. Legion because they’re annoying to go against and Freddy for the exact reason you do. Although I don’t screw over my team by DC’ing. However I’m not completely clean because I have salty DC’ed before as I’m pretty sure we all have.

  • ArrozArroz Member Posts: 1,434

    @Delfador said:

    @Arroz said:

    @Delfador said:
    The most boring killer is hands down the legion.

    Other than him, I don't know. If the team is bad, going against spirits and nurses is just frustrating because you do everything you could do and then the next person gets downed in like 10 seconds. I don't find them boring though.

    The most enjoyable killers to go against is hillbilly and huntress.

    Lmao, you serious that [BAD WORD] possy killer? the huntress aka broken hitboxes? yeah instachainsaw billy is "fun", the only fun killer to play against is pig and scary myers.

    Please for the love of god, fck off if you don't know how to talk to people.

    Why am I a killer here? I am a solo survivor and I rarely play killers and even then I just play the clown. I almost never touch hillbilly as well.

    My play ratio is less then 9 to 1, 9 being the survivor.

    Lmao, you serious that [BAD WORD] possy survivor? Pig aka the worst killer? Yeah scary myers who can't catch up is so fun.

    Jesus

    The objetive of this game is scare and fun not get everygame the ez 4 kills or the ez escape.. the game is supossed to be scary, for that I mention myers, and I mentioned the pig because when your trap is at 90% is so epic.. more fun than the broken hitboxes with insta down...

  • ArrozArroz Member Posts: 1,434

    @Delfador said:

    @Arroz said:

    @Delfador said:
    The most boring killer is hands down the legion.

    Other than him, I don't know. If the team is bad, going against spirits and nurses is just frustrating because you do everything you could do and then the next person gets downed in like 10 seconds. I don't find them boring though.

    The most enjoyable killers to go against is hillbilly and huntress.

    Lmao, you serious that [BAD WORD] possy killer? the huntress aka broken hitboxes? yeah instachainsaw billy is "fun", the only fun killer to play against is pig and scary myers.

    Please for the love of god, fck off if you don't know how to talk to people.

    Why am I a killer here? I am a solo survivor and I rarely play killers and even then I just play the clown. I almost never touch hillbilly as well.

    My play ratio is less then 9 to 1, 9 being the survivor.

    Lmao, you serious that [BAD WORD] possy survivor? Pig aka the worst killer? Yeah scary myers who can't catch up is so fun.

    Jesus

    And btw the myers need to be so bad for dont catch anyone in the generator, so fck off, is weak but it's fun.

  • DelfadorDelfador Member Posts: 2,553

    @Arroz said:

    @Delfador said:

    @Arroz said:

    @Delfador said:
    The most boring killer is hands down the legion.

    Other than him, I don't know. If the team is bad, going against spirits and nurses is just frustrating because you do everything you could do and then the next person gets downed in like 10 seconds. I don't find them boring though.

    The most enjoyable killers to go against is hillbilly and huntress.

    Lmao, you serious that [BAD WORD] possy killer? the huntress aka broken hitboxes? yeah instachainsaw billy is "fun", the only fun killer to play against is pig and scary myers.

    Please for the love of god, fck off if you don't know how to talk to people.

    Why am I a killer here? I am a solo survivor and I rarely play killers and even then I just play the clown. I almost never touch hillbilly as well.

    My play ratio is less then 9 to 1, 9 being the survivor.

    Lmao, you serious that [BAD WORD] possy survivor? Pig aka the worst killer? Yeah scary myers who can't catch up is so fun.

    Jesus

    And btw the myers need to be so bad for dont catch anyone in the generator, so fck off, is weak but it's fun.

    Dude, have you ever heard something like opinion????????? Hello????????? Fun is subjective??????????

    The OP asks which killer is fun to play as or against. For me the answer is fcking billy or huntress. Who are you fighting with? My opinion?

    For me, going against hillbilly and huntress is the most fun, why would you call me possy for saying what I think is fun?

    Going against Myers and Pig is not fcking fun for fcking me? It is dull and I don't like it? Are you going to change my opinion with calling me possy? Why would you make an offensive comment out of that? Am I not allowed to say which killer is fun or not?

    Why would you not say which killers are most fun to play as or against like every other user on this thread rather than attack a forum user for saying their opinion? Read the [BAD WORD] thread, nobody attacked anybody for their fcking opinion except for you.

    What is your problem?

  • ZarathosZarathos Member Posts: 848
    edited February 2019
    Without a doubt hag is the most boring because they are usually incredibly boring because most hags just focus on a single target. Obsses over keeping hook presure often wondering back to hooks even if no trap was triggered. A good hag who is everywhere is enjoyable to play against because at least theres is some interaction with pallets and vaults. 

    For me the boring killer is doctor as his shock serves only to be a time sink that effects have little to no impact on early high ranked players. His power is limited in what pallets he can actually shock and hit in. I also prefer to track via hearing and survivours screaming across the map messes with my ability to track survivours who are trying to hide in grass close by. 
  • NikkiwhatNikkiwhat Member Posts: 1,127
    Hillbilly is the most boring for me to play. I have way more fun with every orher Killer, either I M1 or bait a Chainsaw amd it just feels too easy *slow shrugs*

    To VS against as Survivor, Hillbilly or Hag.  Hillbilly because every Hillbilly I've faced is a huge tunneler or face camper.  For Hag Because teammates potato so hard VS her
  • Rebel_RavenRebel_Raven Member Posts: 1,654
    The ones with zero chill. 
    Their goal is just to plow through the game as fast, and as ruthlessly as possible. 

    Am I saying they should stop? Nope. Just saying it's boring to get mauled by a killer.
Sign In or Register to comment.